Search

Bioethikos: Bringing Life to Bioethics

Pharmacist Conscience Rights Denied

July 6th, 2016 by Dr. Dennis Sullivan

Mortar

Disappointing news from the United States Supreme Court: Pharmacists in the state of Washington have no conscience protections in regard to contraceptive drugs, even those that may induce abortion. In the case of Stormans v. Wiesman, the owners of Ralph’s Thriftway Pharmacy declined to stock certain contraceptives, such as Plan B, that may cause an early abortion. Dispensing such a drug conflicts with the sincere pro-life views of Kevin Stormans and his family.

In the past, when abortifacient drugs were requested, the Stormans would simply and graciously refer the client to one of “more than 30 other pharmacies within five miles of Ralph’s.” This type of arrangement is a time-honored move that has been legal and ethical in all 50 states – until now. Recently enacted State Board of Pharmacy rules now require dispensing all contraceptive agents, regardless of their mechanism of action, and regardless of any ethical views held by pharmacists. The Stormans family sued to retain their right of conscience.

An unfavorable Ninth Circuit Court ruling led to an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, which on June 28th denied certiorari, that is, they refused to hear the case. In his written dissent, Justice Samuel Alito described the clearly anti-religious bias of the high court:

This case is an ominous sign. At issue are Washington State regulations that are likely to make a pharmacist unemployable if he or she objects on religious grounds to dispensing certain prescription medications. There are strong reasons to doubt whether the regulations were adopted for — or that they actually serve — any legitimate purpose. And there is much evidence that the impetus for the adoption of the regulations was hostility to pharmacists whose religious beliefs regarding abortion and contraception are out of step with prevailing opinion in the State.

 

The impact of this ruling will be widespread, and directly affects healthcare professionals throughout the Ninth Circuit Court’s jurisdiction, which includes nine western states. A similar law is currently pending in California (part of the Ninth Circuit).

Make no mistake: conscience rights are under attack. Healthcare professionals of faith may be driven from their vocation by these draconian regulations. Christians must take a stand, and we must pray.

National Review

Alliance Defending Freedom

 

 

Leave a Reply